Benteen / Custer Homes for Sale

Benteen / Custer Homes for Sale

Welcome to the enchanting Benteen / Custer subdivision, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Atlanta, Georgia. This vibrant community, located in Fulton County, offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

The Benteen / Custer area boasts a rich tapestry of history and culture, with tree-lined streets and charming homes that reflect the warmth of Southern living. Here, you’ll find a diverse selection of residences, from cozy bungalows to spacious single-family homes, all designed to cater to various lifestyles and preferences. With homes for sale in this delightful neighborhood, there’s something for everyone, whether you’re a first-time buyer or looking to upgrade your living space.

One of the standout features of Benteen / Custer is its strong sense of community. Residents enjoy easy access to local parks, recreational facilities, and vibrant shopping districts, all within a short drive or leisurely stroll. The area is also well-connected to Atlanta’s public transportation, making commuting a breeze.

In addition to its convenient location, Benteen / Custer is known for its excellent schools and family-friendly atmosphere. The surrounding neighborhoods offer a plethora of dining options, entertainment venues, and cultural attractions, ensuring that you’ll never run out of things to do.

Explore the homes for sale in Benteen / Custer today and discover the perfect place to call home in this thriving Atlanta community. Your dream home awaits!

Newest Benteen / Custer Homes for Sale

$1,375,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 10765647 MLS
This unusual "house on the hill" is a gem: a large, inviting home of comfortable, modern livability sitting in a wooded enclave in the urban heart of Atlanta, offering the rare combination of estate-style privacy and central-city convenience. Set on approximately .75 acres with an adjacent lot, the property presents an exceptional opportunity for expansion, guest house, pool, or future customization. Completely stripped down to studs and rebuilt in 2016, the house stands out for its notable characteristics of the modern eclectic school of architecture, featuring towers, bay alcoves, high ceilings, unusually generous closets and storage spaces, and oversized windows that bring abundant natural light throughout. With 5 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, the 4,700' home was designed for comfortable everyday living with quality craftsmanship - hardwood floors, solid wood cabinets and doors, stone counters, and ceramics in all bathrooms. (Note: lighting fixtures and mirrors convey, and fullpartially furnished option is available.) # On the main floor, the home opens to expansive spaces including a 2-story atrium foyer with 10-foot ceilings and an unusually large living room centered around a fireplace and showcasing 3 walls of windows rising to the 20' ceiling. A chef's kitchen (appliances convey) seamlessly leads through the butler's pantry to a dining room with a charming bay alcove. Another impressive feature is the primary bedroom set within its own tower, featuring a 15' ceiling in the suite along with 4 closets, double vanities, soaking tub, and glass shower. Up the winding staircase, the upper floor features a family room (all TVs convey) anchoring 3 large bedrooms, each connected to bathrooms. The lower level and both garages are fully sheet-rocked for fireproofing and insurance purposes. This level includes a finished playroom, workshop, wine closet, and 3 walk-in rooms offering flexibility for storage, hobbies, or fitness. # The home was also thoughtfully designed for gracious entertainment and includes an oversized 25 x 35 pergola deck - a perfect setting for fresco dining and gatherings, as well as a firepit and screened gazebo off the front porch which makes outdoor relaxation especially pleasant (Note: outdoor furniture conveys). The property is beautifully landscaped. More than 100 fir trees line the perimeter, creating a sense of seclusion rarely found intown. A gated driveway leads to the distinctive terraced frontage and stately entrance stairs of the house and follows along the dramatic dry-stone retaining walls to various parking enclaves (8-10 cars). The property also boasts an ornamental tree orchard, many 50' tall trees, and multiple planted beds containing more than 100 perennials and evergreens. At night, the illuminated property creates an estate-like ambiance and architectural character unlike anything nearby. # Despite its peaceful setting, the home remains exceptionally convenient - just minutes from downtown and midtown, the airport, restaurants, and shopping. It also sits amidst a variety of public and charter schools, some offering highly regarded immersion and baccalaureate programs. Finally, it is strategically situated for easy travel in and out of the city because of nearby access to 3 highways. # This is an exceptional opportunity to own an architecturally distinctive property that combines privacy, elegance, modern comfort, and lasting value in one of Atlanta's most central locations.

1125 Custer Avenue SE, Atlanta

Listing courtesy of Atlanta Communities.

Start Your Search

© 2026 Georgia MLS. All rights reserved. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.